Why I Hate the Military’s Savings Deposit Program (SDP)

The military’s Savings Deposit Program (SDP) is a financial benefit to troops stationed in a combat zone, hazardous duty area, and a few other qualifying locations around the globe.  Members of the military can deposit up to $10,000 and earn a guaranteed 10% APY that accrues quarterly.  Sounds like a great deal, right?  A guaranteed 10% interest rate in today’s economy is pretty good, but I wouldn’t (and haven’t) touched the program with a ten foot pole.  And here’s why…

  

I do not trust the military finance system.  Like most Soldiers, I have been on the receiving end of “No Pay Dues”, and it’s not a pretty sight if you do not have your 3 to 6 month emergency fund in place.  To deposit money into the system, you have to begin allotments or submit cash collection vouchers.  Then, a person (finance clerk) has to manually put your request into the military’s over bloated, ridiculously complex pay system.  I have heard of more Soldiers having pay problems through this program than any other changes they make to their paychecks, withholdings, etc.  With a quarter of the military moving and changing BAH rates for example every year, there is a huge opportunity for your paycheck to get messed up.  I absolutely hate changing anything with my paycheck for fear that I won’t get paid the next month.

 

I have so little faith in the military’s finance and pay computer system that I refuse to enter into the SDP despite the guaranteed 10% interest rate.  10% is not enough!  Investing is a trade off between risk and return.  Classic finance theory states that the riskier the investment is, the more return you should require from it.  SDP is very risky to me.  I can’t sleep at night worrying that $10,000 of my hard earned COMBAT pay is going to be tied up for months because of computer and human errors.  I would rather invest that money in a good, growth mutual fund even if it earned less interest.  Members of the military have too much to worry about in Iraq and Afghanistan than whether their investments, paycheck, and household budgets are running amuck. 

 

Another reason that I do not like the program is that it is incredibly illiquid.  You cannot withdraw the money anytime you want to.  You have to go into the finance office and manually stop the allotment and wait for the military finance office to process your request.  I recently had a Soldier who needed to stop the allotment depositing money from his paycheck into his SDP account, but the first month the finance clerk messed up the transaction in the computer, and then the second month my Soldier caught the error after the transaction closing date.  So, now he has had three months of additional money withdrawn from his paycheck and deposited into his SDP, which is already maxed out and not earning interest anywhere.  See why I love the program?

 

Another point to consider is the tax implications.  Although federal income earned in combat zone is tax-free, interest accrued on earnings deposited into the SDP is actually taxable.  Funds can be left in an SDP account indefinitely, but the account will stop accruing interest 90 days after a member returns from war.  And withdraws may only be made upon leaving the combat zone. 

 

The entire deposit $10,000 in order to earn $1,000 in interest is also almost a misnomer too.  The military has made it very hard to deposit $10,000 to earn your entire $1,000.  A service member cannot deposit an amount into the program exceed a service member’s monthly current pay and allowances.  It will take most service members months to deposit the entire amount.  You also cannot begin contributing to the program until the 31st day you have been in a combat zone.  So, you are already loosing a month of interest.  The government has to let you leave your money in the SDP after you return home just to get you 12 months of interest after all the hoops they make you jump through.

 

The military’s entire finance system needs more transparency.  Servicemembers need to know right away if there is something wrong with their paychecks, and they need to be able to correct problems right away when they are found.  I should not have to hold my breath every two weeks waiting to see if this week is the week where I once again see a “No Pay Due”.

Share and Enjoy: These icons link to social book marking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.

Add to Technorati Favorites Delicious Del.icio.us Digg!


USAMilitaryMedals.com Military Medals Store

Advertisements

8 Responses to Why I Hate the Military’s Savings Deposit Program (SDP)

  1. Patrick says:

    I used this program when I deployed, as did my wife. We were both in a situation where we were able to put the money in and leave it there without worrying about liquidity, so that didn’t bother me. I enjoyed the 10% returns, and if given the chance, would use it again. But I’m out of the military now, so no such luck on my end!

    But, I do agree with your views on it – if you don’t have an emergency fund in place and may need access to the money, I don’t recommend using this program. Too many things can go wrong and it is a hassle to deal with.

  2. Bill says:

    I’d be willing to give the SDP a shot. 10%, That’s a great guaranteed rate of return. I’ll probably dump some money into it.
    I agree about the folks down at Finance, they screw a lot of things up, I think they get ribbons for it in fact. When I screw up my job I go to jail. Finance screws up peoples pay for months at a time, overpaying, then they got to pay it all back ASAP. Yet that’s okay, and they make it out like you’re irrational when you go in their frustrated. Nothing happens to them, they still get their 3 hour luncheons when they open at 9am and have PT during work hours. Are you kidding me?
    They are lucky we are not customers with a choice and that they have no competition. If they were an actual business, they would have gone out of business a long time ago. That goes for almost all of our service related career fields.

  3. youproblog says:

    Hi, I found your blog on yahoo. I’m pretty happy to have found your website because I think it is informative! I will definitely come back! Great resource for my students. Youproblog

  4. […] Why I Hate the Military’s Savings Deposit Program (SDP). I used the military’s Savings Deposit Program a couple times while I was deployed, and for me it was a good investment option. But there are a lot of reasons why this may not be for you. Before investing your money there, be sure to understand the pros and cons. […]

  5. Admiring the time and effort you place into your weblog and detailed knowledge you offer! I will

  6. Casey says:

    Personally, I used it in the past an had zero problems. If you write them a check for your deposits, then you take the uncertainty out of allotments. If you have enough foresight to tell your soldiers prior to deploying to take a few blank checks – it makes life a little easier. I think that anyone who refuses to take a little time to plan accordingly to invest in the SDP because of complaints about the Military pay system deserves exactly what they get – zero extra cash in their pocket on the backside of the deployment.

    I do not understand how a person can legitimately complain about recieving 10% interest on a investment – especially today! Withdrawing was pretty painless as you log into mypay and click on the withdraw button for your SDP. Within a few days of them processing your request your money is put into your account just like the rest of your pay.

    Leaders should encourage their soldiers to partake in this program. You are foolish not to.

  7. Standard 401k Details…

    […]Why I Hate the Military’s Savings Deposit Program (SDP) « Military Money Might[…]…

  8. TUEZT | Products Review | Tips and Tricks | Scam or Not…

    […]Why I Hate the Military’s Savings Deposit Program (SDP) « Military Money Might[…]…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  • %d bloggers like this: